beteo ALM Experts Blog

Blog

  • Is the SAP Enhancement Package Framework the Hoped-For “Cure-All”?

    Is the SAP Enhancement Package Framework the hoped-for “cure-all”?

    The concept of Enhancement Packages (Enhancement Packages Framework, short EhPs) is simply brilliant. However, when one considers how long SAP — as the standard software supplier for business software par excellence — took to establish this software logistics discipline, one can no longer speak of brilliance. What the absence of this framework has cost customers until now, each customer should calculate for themselves.

    From a software logistics perspective, SAP has finally done its homework, but again (as in my blog on Solution Manager) only with a focus on the standard software. The EhPs unfortunately still do not address customer implementations. Impact analyses as provided by Intellicorp and Panaya for the largest investments of an SAP implementation are non-existent.

    What does this mean for SAP customers who have already made the step to EhPs (prerequisite: SAP NetWeaver 7.0)? For those not yet on SAP NW 7.0, the conventional SAP upgrade is unfortunately still a prerequisite.

    Technical basis: The corresponding EhPs can be applied in a time-neutral manner, meaning the physical effort remains, but the direct temporal dependency of the business-technical follow-up work (business-technical application of EhPs) is decoupled.

    Business-technical: In a first step (preparation), all additional requirements for new functionalities delivered by SAP in the EhP must be collected. Based on these, a concurrent analysis of the configured base (ALM – investment protection) and an evaluation of the new functionality on SAP’s demo systems must be performed. Only through this analysis can the scope of business-technical EhP application be determined.

    The activation of individual Business Switches makes the impact analysis even more challenging: now it must really be evaluated which “transaction areas” are actually used in the organization. The consequences you’ve probably already experienced: with every upgrade or now “business-technical application of EhPs,” the entire implemented application portfolio is rebuilt again, so that the new technical functions can be assured on the basis of the old technical functionality — instead of actively managing only the delta between old and new functionality.

    Conclusion: The time-consuming identification, implementation and testing of new business content remains the same, if not increased by additional complexity. Due to the newly available business functionality, concurrent impact analysis becomes ever more complex and therefore more time-consuming. The temporal decoupling of the technical application of EhPs can save time. However, this time saving should at least be reinvested in impact analysis, in order not to risk production shutdowns.

    🇩🇪 Diesen Beitrag auf Deutsch lesen

  • Cultural Patterns and Corporate Success

    A Gallup poll from last year in German companies shows: 67 percent of employees make work to rule. The cause was the lack of leadership culture, of real self-evident characteristics such as esteem, respect, personal development opportunity and involvement in decisions. The damage to the economy because of the lack of innovation and frustration of customers was projected at around 100 billion euros.

    Could it be that the current economic and financial crisis is the result of a wrong cultural development? Not a crisis of the economic system itself, but a crisis of a specific business and management culture that in recent decades has increasingly lost its humane orientation?

    Cultural patterns are deeply embedded in organizations and are difficult to change. They are reflected in how people interact, how decisions are made, how success is defined and measured. When cultural patterns focus exclusively on short-term financial metrics, they inevitably lead to behaviors that are harmful in the long run.

    Corporate success, in the broadest sense, requires a culture that balances multiple objectives: financial performance, customer satisfaction, employee engagement, and social responsibility. Companies that excel in all these dimensions create sustainable value and are more resilient in times of crisis.

    beteo believes that this insight is particularly relevant for consulting companies: We must not only help our clients optimize their IT systems and processes, but also help them build the organizational capabilities and cultural foundations that enable sustainable success.

    The path to a healthier business culture requires courageous leadership, genuine commitment to values, and the willingness to measure success by more than just short-term financial results.

    🇩🇪 Diesen Beitrag auf Deutsch lesen

  • How Tool-Based SAP Change Control Helps SAP Customers

    HP PPM in combination with beteo’s SAP Change Control Current Practice can help SAP customers to reduce cost and risk in the SAP change process. This article summarizes the potential benefits, challenges and approaches of implementing a SAP change control solution based on HP PPM and beteo SAP Change Control Current Practice, as well as illustrating a sample customer reference.

    Potential Benefits of a Tool-Based SAP Change Control Solution:

    Reducing cost and risk is the primary motivation for implementing a structured SAP change control process. Key benefits include: improved planning and prioritization of changes, better coordination between projects and maintenance activities, reduced risk of transport conflicts and errors, complete audit trail of all changes, and faster resolution of critical issues.

    Challenges in implementing SAP change control include: the complexity of SAP landscapes with multiple systems and clients, the need to balance speed of change with risk management, integration with existing processes and tools, and user adoption and training.

    beteo’s SAP Change Control Current Practice provides a proven framework that addresses these challenges. It combines standardized processes with HP PPM as the central tool for change request management and transport coordination. The framework has been implemented successfully at multiple SAP customers in Switzerland and provides a solid foundation for reliable SAP change management.

    A typical customer reference: A large Swiss manufacturing company was experiencing frequent transport conflicts and system instabilities due to uncoordinated changes. After implementing beteo’s SAP Change Control solution based on HP PPM, transport conflicts were reduced by 70% and system stability improved significantly.

    🇩🇪 Diesen Beitrag auf Deutsch lesen

  • Integrating Jira and HP Quality Center

    Testing departments use HP Quality Center (QC) for quality management and testing activities. Besides managing test requirements, it also helps them to compile test plans, and to conduct and monitor testing. In addition, Quality Center gives them a way to manage all defect tracking.

    However, developers often work with their own tools to manage bugs and defects, and to monitor problem-fixes. This is often Jira, an issue tracking and project management tool from Atlassian. This creates a situation where two different tools are used for defect management: HP Quality Center on the testing side and Jira on the development side.

    The integration of Jira and HP Quality Center bridges this gap by synchronizing defects between the two tools. When a tester creates a defect in Quality Center, it can automatically be created in Jira as well. When a developer updates the status in Jira, the change is reflected in Quality Center. This bidirectional synchronization ensures that both teams always have access to the latest defect status.

    beteo has implemented such integrations for various clients and has developed expertise in the technical and organizational aspects of tool integration. The benefits include: elimination of duplicate data entry, improved communication between testing and development teams, better traceability from defects to fixes, and more accurate reporting across both tools.

    The integration can be implemented using various approaches, including commercial integration tools and custom development. The choice of approach depends on the specific requirements and the technical environment.

    🇩🇪 Diesen Beitrag auf Deutsch lesen

  • SAP Consolidation: A Challenge to Further Development

    In a highly interesting and descriptive blog posting on the SAP Community Network, Tao Zhang, who works for Benteler Group, discusses the SAP consolidation process. His article focuses on the challenges and potential benefits, approaching the issue from the company’s perspective.

    As I see it, the biggest challenges facing SAP system environment consolidation projects in the medium term are: First, the planning and coordination of the decommissioning or consolidation of the current SAP landscape while ongoing business operations must be maintained. Second, the management of the complex interdependencies between SAP systems, especially when multiple clients and custom developments are involved.

    SAP consolidation is much more than just a technical merging of systems. It requires careful analysis of all business processes, master data, configurations, and custom developments. The consolidation must not disrupt ongoing business operations, which makes it one of the most challenging IT projects.

    beteo has extensive experience in SAP consolidation projects. Our approach combines detailed analysis using specialized tools with proven project management methods. We help our clients plan and execute SAP consolidations that minimize business risk while maximizing the expected benefits of the consolidated system landscape.

    The benefits of a successful SAP consolidation include: reduced operational costs, simplified system maintenance, better data quality through harmonization, and improved performance through optimized infrastructure.

    🇩🇪 Diesen Beitrag auf Deutsch lesen

  • beteo Successfully Assists SBB in Implementing HP Quality Center

    Test factory based on HP Quality Center is now available for all SBB projects. When it came to the complex and systematic implementation of the software quality management program, SBB called upon the Swiss Application Lifecycle Management consulting company beteo. SBB is utilizing HP Quality Center in its test environment, where standardized test procedures and consistent test management can now dramatically simplify and optimize the testing process.

    SBB (Swiss Federal Railways) is one of Switzerland’s largest enterprises and one of the most important public transport companies in Europe. The implementation of a standardized test environment across all projects was a major challenge, requiring careful planning and execution.

    beteo’s approach was to establish a test factory concept based on HP Quality Center that provides a centralized, standardized testing infrastructure for all SBB projects. This enables consistent quality management, better test coverage, and significant efficiency gains in the testing process.

    The project results demonstrate the value of professional ALM consulting: standardized test procedures, improved test documentation, better traceability between requirements and test cases, and more efficient defect management. The implementation has set a new standard for software quality management at SBB.

    🇩🇪 Diesen Beitrag auf Deutsch lesen

  • SAP Upgrade: Analysis Procedures and Results

    SAP upgrades are regularly a major challenge for SAP customers and their IT teams. The preparation and execution of an SAP upgrade requires careful analysis of the existing system and the planned target system. beteo has extensive experience in SAP upgrade projects and has developed proven procedures for upgrade analysis.

    The most critical question in an SAP upgrade is: “Which of our custom developments and configurations will be affected by the upgrade?” This requires a comprehensive impact analysis that identifies all affected objects and assesses the effort required to adapt them.

    Key analysis steps include: technical upgrade analysis (which standard programs have changed?), custom code impact analysis (which Z-programs are affected?), configuration impact analysis (which customizing settings need to be reviewed?), and interface analysis (which interfaces to external systems need to be tested?).

    beteo has developed standardized procedures and uses specialized tools such as IntelliCorp LiveCompare for these analyses. Our experience shows that a thorough upgrade analysis significantly reduces the risk of an SAP upgrade project and enables better planning and cost estimation.

    The results of the analysis provide the basis for a realistic project plan, including resource planning, timeline, and budget. They also enable early identification and resolution of potential problems before the actual upgrade begins.

    🇩🇪 Diesen Beitrag auf Deutsch lesen

  • Transport Management: SAP CTS Will Hardly Straighten It Out

    Based on many years of experience in SAP solution management and Application Lifecycle Management, beteo is convinced that the control of software transport in complex SAP system landscapes is one of the most challenging tasks facing SAP customers. At the same time, it is one of the most underestimated tasks.

    Many SAP customers believe that the SAP Change and Transport System (CTS) covers all their transport management requirements. However, CTS is merely a transport tool. It has no knowledge about which changes in a SAP system are related to each other, and which software transports must therefore be transported together. So, using CTS alone, it is impossible to coordinate transport activities in a complex SAP system landscape reliably.

    Basically, the most important question which must be answered for any change in the system landscape is: “Which other parts of the system landscape are affected by this change?” CTS provides no answer to this question. The answer requires a comprehensive solution management tool that manages all change- and transport-relevant dependencies.

    In SAP environments, transport management is even more challenging than in other IT environments due to SAP’s highly integrated architecture. In SAP environments with multiple clients and systems, just keeping an overview of the transport landscape and the transport activities is already challenging.

    beteo’s experience shows that standardized processes and tools for transport management can significantly reduce costs and risks. We help our clients establish reliable transport management in their SAP environments.

    🇩🇪 Diesen Beitrag auf Deutsch lesen

  • SAP Business Process Change Analyzer – Does It Analyze Business Processes?

    Accompanied by considerable fanfare, SAP co-CEO Leo Apotheker introduced an SAP Solution Manager module called the SAP Business Process Change Analyzer (SAP BPCA) at TechEd in Berlin. So, what’s behind it? Can the Business Process Change Analyzer fulfill the expectations that its name suggests?

    The fact that SAP has even introduced the BPCA seems to indicate the value it has assigned to impact analysis. Impact analysis is a topic that has been addressed in various articles in the beteo blog. Unfortunately SAP and its “Business Process” Change Analyzer deal exclusively with the technical analysis of transactions and programs. So, anyone who expects SAP’s analytical offering to include the overlying logical areas will be in for a long wait.

    It appears that BPCA is based on a run-time analysis, which makes it impossible to conduct impact analysis directly in the corresponding production environment. The result is that only corresponding predefined scenarios can be analyzed with BPCA.

    The question we must ask is why SAP didn’t turn to “standard” analysis tools like LiveCompare from Intellicorp, Panaya from Panaya Inc., RBE from IBIS or CIT for SAP from HP. These are based on “smarter” approaches to impact analysis and impact management, and their merits have been proven through real-world usage.

    Summary: Once again, on paper SAP’s BPCA satisfies most of the items found on typical RFP checklists pertaining to impact analysis. However, upon closer scrutiny many higher expectations that customers have regarding a bona-fide business process change analyzer have not been met.

    🇩🇪 Diesen Beitrag auf Deutsch lesen

  • SAP Solution Manager – Does It Manage SAP Solutions?

    I was fortunate to attend various presentations on the topic of SAP’s solution management at SAP TechEd 2008 Berlin. My expectations regarding SAP solution management would be that SAP could finally take on the task of solution management for specific customer implementation scenarios, and that it would do so in a comprehensive manner. Sadly, this has not yet been achieved.

    Even after visiting the solution management presentations I was disappointed to find that even though the SAP Solution Manager does fulfill the requirements to manage a standard SAP system, key functions pertaining to the solution management of specific SAP customer implementations are missing. Apparently the Solution Manager remains primarily a gateway to the customer’s infrastructure.

    SAP’s marketing, however, cleverly packages the Solution Manager as a comprehensive lifecycle management solution for specific SAP customer environments, even though basic requirements for bona-fide solution management using SolMan—such as customization version control or dependency management among individual software components—are nonexistent.

    Summary: It is somewhat disillusioning that SAP still hasn’t directed the SAP lifecycle management toward solution management for its thousands of different customer implementations. Despite the potential benefits for all SAP customers, the lifecycle management solution bearing the wonderful name of Solution Manager is still mainly a software logistics-specific bridgehead for SAP standard software.

    Note: beteo has implemented comprehensive SAP solution management for actual customer implementations based on standard processes and standard software.

    🇩🇪 Diesen Beitrag auf Deutsch lesen

Powered by